This browser is not actively supported anymore. For the best passle experience, we strongly recommend you upgrade your browser.

Search our site

Viewpoints

| 1 minute read

It's a ๐Ÿ‘ from the Canadian courts for emojis

A Canadian judge has ruled that a thumbs up emoji can signal contractual acceptance. The case was, unsurprisingly, very fact specific. There was a longstanding previous course of dealing between the claimant (a grain buyer) and the defendant (a farmer): the claimant would typically text contracts to the defendant who would accept them by responding with a โ€œLooks goodโ€, an โ€œOkโ€ or a โ€œYupโ€. On this occasion, after the claimant texted a contract for the purchase of flax to the defendant, the defendant responded with a ๐Ÿ‘. The claimant took that to mean the contract was accepted, the defendant argued the ๐Ÿ‘ simply meant that the text message itself had been received. 

After hearing arguments on the meaning of the ๐Ÿ‘ (and the defendantโ€™s counsel tersely objecting that his client was โ€œnot an expert in emojisโ€), the judge turned to the (online) dictionary definition: โ€œit is used to express assent, approval or encouragement in digital communications, especially in western culturesโ€. With this and the previous dealings between the claimant and defendant in mind, the judge found in favour of the claimant; the contract had been accepted and damages were owed. 

It remains to be seen whether the courts of England and Wales will take the same view as and when a similar question comes before them (it is surely a question of when, not if). In the meantime, this will serve as an novel cautionary tale that raises some interesting points around the use and interpretation of emojis and also the lack of formality needed to form a binding contract. 

โ€œThis court readily acknowledges that a ๐Ÿ‘ emoji is a non-traditional means to โ€œsignโ€ a document but nevertheless under these circumstances this was a valid way to convey the two purposes of a โ€œsignatureโ€ โ€“ to identify the signator (Chris using his unique cell phone number) and as I have found above โ€“ to convey Achterโ€™s acceptance of the flax contractโ€

Tags

dispute resolution